Visual Summary

Charts, graphs, and quick statistics

Reading time: ~3 minutes

Visual Summary: Chomsky Claims Verification

Verification Status Overview

Total Claims: 20

✅ Verified:        ████████████ 11 (55%)
🔍 Not Found:       ██████████   9 (45%)
❌ Contradicted:    (none)

Evidence Strength

Top 5 Verified Claims by Evidence Count

1. Operational Criterion      ████████████████████ 12,440 excerpts
2. Telford Taylor             ████████████████     7,049+ excerpts
3. Bombing Cities             ████████             4,422 excerpts
4. Ex Post Facto              ███                   1,709 excerpts
5. Nanking Massacre           █                     88 excerpts

Claim Categories

✅ Verified Categories

Nuremberg Principles - Operational Criterion (4/4 verified)

  • How war crimes were determined
  • Strongest evidence found

Nuremberg Principles - Telford Taylor (4/4 verified)

  • Prosecutor’s statements
  • Book references
  • All verified

Nuremberg Principles - Ex Post Facto (1/1 verified)

  • Retroactive application
  • Verified

Tokyo Trials - General Assessment (2/3 verified)

  • US priorities
  • Nanking massacre
  • One claim not found

🔍 Not Found Categories

Tokyo Trials - General Yamashita (0/1 found)

  • Requires Tokyo Trial documents
  • May need library access

Tokyo Trials - Justice Pal Dissent (0/5 found)

  • Requires Pal’s dissent document
  • May need library access

Nuremberg Trials - Admiral Gernetz (0/1 found)

  • Documents not found
  • May need different search

American Presidents (0/1 found)

  • Requires external analysis
  • Outside scope of trial documents

Key Findings Matrix

Claim Category Claims Verified Evidence Strength
Operational Criterion 4 4 ✅ Very Strong
Telford Taylor 4 4 ✅ Very Strong
Bombing 4 4 ✅ Strong
Ex Post Facto 1 1 ✅ Strong
Tokyo Trials 6 2 ✅ Limited
Other 1 0 🔍 N/A

Evidence Quality Assessment

High Confidence (80-100%)

  • Operational Criterion: 100%
  • Bombing Cities: 100%
  • Telford Taylor: 100%
  • Ex Post Facto: 100%
  • Nanking: 100%

Medium Confidence (50-79%)

  • US Priorities (1930s): 80%

Low Confidence / Not Found (0-49%)

  • Tokyo Trials claims: 0% (documents not found)
  • Gernetz case: 0% (documents not found)

Verification Pattern

What Was Verified

✅ Claims about how trials worked (operational criterion)
✅ Claims about who was involved (Telford Taylor)
✅ Claims about what was prosecuted (bombing, ex post facto)
✅ Claims about Nuremberg trials (stronger documentation)

What Wasn’t Found

🔍 Claims about Tokyo trials (weaker documentation)
🔍 Claims requiring specific documents (Pal dissent, Yamashita)
🔍 Claims requiring external sources (presidential actions)

Confidence Levels

High Confidence (100%):     ████████████ 11 claims
Medium Confidence (80%):    █           1 claim
Not Found (0%):             █████████   9 claims

Source Verification

Total URLs Tested:     1,826
Unique Base URLs:     110
Verified Accessible:   110 (100%)
Failed Tests:         0

Summary Statistics

  • Claims Analyzed: 20
  • Verified: 11 (55%)
  • Evidence Excerpts: 30,000+
  • Source Documents: 110 verified URLs
  • Contradictions: 0
  • Average Confidence: 54%

This visual summary provides quick overview of verification results. For details, see other documents.